When a famous DP spreads technical myths, we fact-check the claims!
Here’s the verdict on 7 key arguments from Steve Yedlin’s controversial color science presentation:
โ YEDLIN’S CLAIM:
“Colors outside Rec.709 = GARISH”
โ
REALITY CHECK:
Digital cinema = P3 ๐ฌ
Subjective bias โ technical truth
YEDLIN’S CLAIM:
“Rec.2020 = SDR color space”
โ
TECHNICALLY TRUE โ ๏ธ
BT.2020 is an SDR/WCG standard.
HDR uses BT.2100, which reuses
BT.2020 primaries. ๐
โ YEDLIN’S CLAIM:
“WCG only for lasers”
โ
REALITY CHECK:
โ64% real-world colors beyond Rec.709 ๐บ๐ ๐ด
โ YEDLIN’S CLAIM:
“BT.1886 = color space”
โ
REALITY CHECK:
BT.1886 = transfer function โ๏ธ
(No primaries!)
โ YEDLIN’S CLAIM:
“CIE HULL”
โ
REALITY CHECK:
Correct term = CIE 1931 xy chromaticity diagram ๐
YEDLIN’S CLAIM:
“WCG not specific to HDR”
โ
TECHNICALLY TRUE โ ๏ธ
WCG can exist in SDR BUT
streamers exclusively deliver
WCG via HDR formats. ๐ป
โ YEDLIN’S CLAIM:
“Rec.1886”
โ
REALITY CHECK:
ITU-R BT.1886 is the standard ๐
(“Rec.1886” doesn’t exist)
๐ Want the FULL technical breakdown?
We’ve dissected every contradiction in our deep dive:
Debunking the Debunker: Steve Yedlinโs Color Science Contradictions Exposed
Leave a Reply